Idle No More activists in Happy Valley-Goose Bay, Corner Brook, Stephenville, and St. John's are organizing rallies and protests for Sunday, January 27th.
--Solidarity March in Happy Valley-Goose Bay (with Friends of the Grand River/Mistashipu)
--Facebook event for Corner Brook organized by 4 O'Clock Whistle (read press release here)
--Facebook event for St. John's organized by Idle No More St. John's
--Stephenville event Sacred Fire hosted by Bay St. George Cultural Circle,
Idle No More protests have been taking place in NL since early December 2012. The timeline below highlights a few of the many actions in solidarity with the INM movement. This post is intended to promote solidarity as
well as to consolidate information, so please help us add to/make corrections to this list by leaving a comment or sending us an email.
Dec 10th — Idle No More solidarity protest in Happy Valley-Goose Bay, Labrador. Video here.
Dec 11th --- NunatuKavut elders arrested for trespassing
Dec 18th --- Dennis Burden arrested
Dec 21st --- Stephenville Idle No More protest
Dec 21st --- St. John's Idle No More solidarity rally
Jan 4, 2013 —The Idle No More campaign held protests in Corner Brook and Grand Falls-Windsor.
Jan 11, 2013 — NunaTuKavut Community Council Idle No More solidarity protest
Jan 12, 2013 — Idle No More St. John's Round Dance at Avalon Mall
Monday, January 21, 2013
Saturday, January 12, 2013
#IdleNoMore Flashmob-Rounddance at Avalon Mall St. John's
Occupy NL stands in solidarity with Idle No More activists in St. John's on January 12th 2013. Here's some of the pictures and videos from today's event. Please copy/download/share and distribute far and wide (sharing is caring). To link up with Idle No More in St. John's, check out the facebook group.
| Kicked out in the rain, but still singing and drumming! |
Thursday, January 10, 2013
The Rent Is Too Damn High (in St. John's).
As everyone knows, housing prices in St. John's have been skyrocketing. Between 2008 and 2012, house prices rose 69% and rental prices rose 25% in nominal terms.
So what do we make of this? According to this CBC story, this price surge means "the St. John's market doing almost twice as well as the Canadian average" as though rising prices are clearly a good thing. But while rising housing prices are a boon to the real estate industry and to home owners who are planning to sell their homes and move elsewhere, it is bad news for renters, bad news for people hoping to move to the city, and as I hope to persuade you, bad for the NL economy.
Tuesday, January 8, 2013
On the current Revolutionary Wave
One way to subvert or stifle a movement is to compartmentalize it.
In a recent CBC interview sociologist Robert Brym compares Occupy and Idle No More:
"The Occupy and Idle No More movements share two characteristics. They both have relatively diffuse demands and decentralized leadership. ... The Occupy movement's demand for greater economic equality seems to have resonated with a large part of the Canadian population, which has experienced growing income disparity and slow growth in real income for decades … In contrast, I believe the public has more mixed feelings about the Idle No More movement."
Movements are often defined in terms of demands, and more rarely tactics. This is what this group is all about, what they want and specifically who they have a beef with. Characteristics are mapped out and then the thing can be known, compartmentalized, and (in some ways) caged.
A somewhat different understanding (though undoubtedly a kind of caging as well) is of the revolutionary wave. Revolutionary wave theory suggests that to understand Idle No More you first have to connect it back to Mohamed Bouazizi and the Arab Spring.
The recent freedom of information release of FBI files show that even before the Occupy movement became "official" it had been anticipated by security forces as building on a revolutionary wave:
"Various online communities and groups have dubbed 17 September 2011 the 'US Day of Rage' and are planning organized protests and assemblies throughout the United States. ... Referencing the demonstrations of the 2011 Arab Spring, the 'US Day of Rage' desires to mimic the revolutionary wave of demonstrations and protests which have occurred in the Arab world."
States know that revolution knows no borders. Indeed, US intelligence admitted a failure to have been caught so off guard when the revolution emerged. From the evidence of infiltration and subversion of Occupy in the FOI release, it is clear security forces took the potential of this revolutionary wave very seriously.
Other states also took preemptive actions to stem the revolution before it could take hold (legal, constitutional, censorship, subversion, repression, etc.). States try to do this in an organized and focused way because revolution means unrest and in the extreme case the collapse of the state itself. This last outcome is more terrifying for the state than losing a war.
A great number of states all over the world are experiencing unrest. Even in countries where protest is generally a bureaucratic thing (Canada) there has been significant unrest (Quebec student movement, Occupy, and now Idle No More). No one should doubt that the state has monitored and tried to subvert expressions of unrest in Canada. No one needs to have a degree in sociology to anticipate the communities that will offer the clearest expressions of unrest.
Many states have made sweeping concessions, held snap elections, installed revolutionary governments, done whatever it takes to just make unrest stop. However, even in countries where the revolution has toppled governments unrest persists. There is no reason to expect this level of unrest will subside any time in the foreseeable future, as this revolutionary wave, and its myriad if sometimes difficult to identify characteristics and demands, just so happens to be taking place against the backdrop of a particularly easy to identify pyramid scheme of capital and power.
In a recent CBC interview sociologist Robert Brym compares Occupy and Idle No More:
"The Occupy and Idle No More movements share two characteristics. They both have relatively diffuse demands and decentralized leadership. ... The Occupy movement's demand for greater economic equality seems to have resonated with a large part of the Canadian population, which has experienced growing income disparity and slow growth in real income for decades … In contrast, I believe the public has more mixed feelings about the Idle No More movement."
Movements are often defined in terms of demands, and more rarely tactics. This is what this group is all about, what they want and specifically who they have a beef with. Characteristics are mapped out and then the thing can be known, compartmentalized, and (in some ways) caged.
A somewhat different understanding (though undoubtedly a kind of caging as well) is of the revolutionary wave. Revolutionary wave theory suggests that to understand Idle No More you first have to connect it back to Mohamed Bouazizi and the Arab Spring.
The recent freedom of information release of FBI files show that even before the Occupy movement became "official" it had been anticipated by security forces as building on a revolutionary wave:
"Various online communities and groups have dubbed 17 September 2011 the 'US Day of Rage' and are planning organized protests and assemblies throughout the United States. ... Referencing the demonstrations of the 2011 Arab Spring, the 'US Day of Rage' desires to mimic the revolutionary wave of demonstrations and protests which have occurred in the Arab world."
States know that revolution knows no borders. Indeed, US intelligence admitted a failure to have been caught so off guard when the revolution emerged. From the evidence of infiltration and subversion of Occupy in the FOI release, it is clear security forces took the potential of this revolutionary wave very seriously.
Other states also took preemptive actions to stem the revolution before it could take hold (legal, constitutional, censorship, subversion, repression, etc.). States try to do this in an organized and focused way because revolution means unrest and in the extreme case the collapse of the state itself. This last outcome is more terrifying for the state than losing a war.
A great number of states all over the world are experiencing unrest. Even in countries where protest is generally a bureaucratic thing (Canada) there has been significant unrest (Quebec student movement, Occupy, and now Idle No More). No one should doubt that the state has monitored and tried to subvert expressions of unrest in Canada. No one needs to have a degree in sociology to anticipate the communities that will offer the clearest expressions of unrest.
Many states have made sweeping concessions, held snap elections, installed revolutionary governments, done whatever it takes to just make unrest stop. However, even in countries where the revolution has toppled governments unrest persists. There is no reason to expect this level of unrest will subside any time in the foreseeable future, as this revolutionary wave, and its myriad if sometimes difficult to identify characteristics and demands, just so happens to be taking place against the backdrop of a particularly easy to identify pyramid scheme of capital and power.
Saturday, January 5, 2013
Why I Believe in Progressive Taxation
This post has been converted into a article in the Independent.
My recent appearance on NTV news to expose the premier's false statements about our tax system prompted a critical response from a viewer. The email is a genuine and thoughtful critique of progressive taxation, and expresses a view that I think is widely held (even by some Occupiers). I reproduce the letter below, followed by a defence of progressive taxation.
"Dear Mr. Baird. I think you got that statement on NTV backwards. A higher rate tax on the wealthy is "regressive" not "progressive".
My recent appearance on NTV news to expose the premier's false statements about our tax system prompted a critical response from a viewer. The email is a genuine and thoughtful critique of progressive taxation, and expresses a view that I think is widely held (even by some Occupiers). I reproduce the letter below, followed by a defence of progressive taxation.
"Dear Mr. Baird. I think you got that statement on NTV backwards. A higher rate tax on the wealthy is "regressive" not "progressive".
Wednesday, January 2, 2013
Provincial Taxes Are Still Regressive
In the previous post I made some estimates of the provincial tax burden of individuals according to income level. I used CRA data for the income tax part, but I was forced to make some assumptions about sales, gas and tobacco taxes. I think the assumptions were reasonable, but they were only rough guesstimates and not empirically derived.
Since then, I've found a CCPA study that estimates tax incidence for lots of different taxes in Canada. It's not perfect for my purposes because the data is Canada-wide not Newfoundland specific, but we can try using their numbers as a check that my earlier estimates are reasonable.
The CCPA lumps together HST, gas, and tobacco into a category they call "commodity taxes". Their estimated tax rate (see table 1) is for the whole country and includes GST. To get something appropriate for Newfoundland I scaled their rate by 0.85. This factor was chosen to make the total tax collected about equal to revenue in recent budgets. I end up with the following chart:
The chart is pretty similar to what I had before, except that the share of income going to taxes starts dropping off for income levels over $85K - roughly the richest 5% of tax filers. The textbook reason for this is that the wealthy save a large share of their income and there is no sales tax on money that isn't spent.
Saturday, December 29, 2012
Taxes in NL Are Deeply Regressive
I've added a small followup to this post here.
In a recent interview with NTV, while addressing the provincial budget deficit, Premier Dunderdale stated that
"16% of people in the province pay 70% of the taxes. We need to talk about that."
The premier seems to feel that most Newfoundlanders (i.e. the non-rich ones) do not pay their fair share of taxes. Perhaps she is setting the stage for a regressive tax hike or perhaps she feels that introducing the idea will make cutbacks more palatable and help her with labour negotiations. In any case, her numbers are bogus and she needs to be called out on it.
I don't know where Dunderdale got her numbers (if anyone knows, please comment), but she is pretty clearly talking about income taxes only, not taxes in general. According to the latest CRA data, the top 17% of income tax filers paid 67% of provincial income taxes in 2009. Conflating "income taxes" with "taxes" (a common trick in right-wing American politics: lucky duckies, we are the 53 percent, the Romney video, etc.) is particularly egregious in the NL context where personal income taxes make up only about 13% of government revenue.
Most people pay more in sales tax than income tax, and many spend more on gas and tobacco taxes than income tax, so focussing exclusively on income tax is deeply misleading. Furthermore, top income tax rates were cut in 2010 meaning that even the share of income taxes paid by the rich is less than Dunderdale's figure (probably closer to 60% than 70%).
In the following chart, I've plotted my estimate of the share of income going provincial taxes as a function of total income of individuals. I've had to make a few assumptions that are explained at the end of this post.
But this is not the end of the story. These taxes only account for about 30% of government revenue. What about the rest?
The government receives about 17% in federal transfers and 7% from corporations. I'm going to ignore these because I'm interested in taxes on people in Newfoundland.
The biggest revenue source is offshore royalties which account for about 35% of revenue. How one understands ownership of oil revenues is crucial to deciding who is carrying the tax burden in this province. My position is that the natural resources of our province belong to the people of our province and that they belong to each of us equally. A poor Newfoundlander has as much claim to our resources as a rich Newfoundlander. If you'll grant that much, then it stands to reason that the offshore royalties belong to each of us equally, the poor as much as the rich. Thus we should treat royalties as personal income that is equally distributed and taxed at 100%.
I treat in the same way the much smaller revenues from mining royalties, NLC revenues, lotteries, driver licenses and so on. This works out to a per capita income of about $5800 a year, of which $5000 comes from oil. Treating this as personal income that is taxed at 100% results in the following chart.
******* Note on Calculations *******
In a recent interview with NTV, while addressing the provincial budget deficit, Premier Dunderdale stated that
"16% of people in the province pay 70% of the taxes. We need to talk about that."
The premier seems to feel that most Newfoundlanders (i.e. the non-rich ones) do not pay their fair share of taxes. Perhaps she is setting the stage for a regressive tax hike or perhaps she feels that introducing the idea will make cutbacks more palatable and help her with labour negotiations. In any case, her numbers are bogus and she needs to be called out on it.
I don't know where Dunderdale got her numbers (if anyone knows, please comment), but she is pretty clearly talking about income taxes only, not taxes in general. According to the latest CRA data, the top 17% of income tax filers paid 67% of provincial income taxes in 2009. Conflating "income taxes" with "taxes" (a common trick in right-wing American politics: lucky duckies, we are the 53 percent, the Romney video, etc.) is particularly egregious in the NL context where personal income taxes make up only about 13% of government revenue.
In the following chart, I've plotted my estimate of the share of income going provincial taxes as a function of total income of individuals. I've had to make a few assumptions that are explained at the end of this post.
People with total income of $10,000 or more pay 10-to-15 percent of their income on these four taxes. The rate grows with income, but only moderately. The top 17% of income tax filers receive 46% of total income and pay about 50% of provincial taxes.
But this is not the end of the story. These taxes only account for about 30% of government revenue. What about the rest?
The government receives about 17% in federal transfers and 7% from corporations. I'm going to ignore these because I'm interested in taxes on people in Newfoundland.
The biggest revenue source is offshore royalties which account for about 35% of revenue. How one understands ownership of oil revenues is crucial to deciding who is carrying the tax burden in this province. My position is that the natural resources of our province belong to the people of our province and that they belong to each of us equally. A poor Newfoundlander has as much claim to our resources as a rich Newfoundlander. If you'll grant that much, then it stands to reason that the offshore royalties belong to each of us equally, the poor as much as the rich. Thus we should treat royalties as personal income that is equally distributed and taxed at 100%.
I treat in the same way the much smaller revenues from mining royalties, NLC revenues, lotteries, driver licenses and so on. This works out to a per capita income of about $5800 a year, of which $5000 comes from oil. Treating this as personal income that is taxed at 100% results in the following chart.
From this perspective, provincial tax rates are deeply regressive. The poorest people are paying close to 40% of their income in taxes, the middle class is paying 20-30%, and the rich are paying about 15%. To use Dunderdale's standard, the richest 17% are only paying about 31% of the total tax burden.
Someone needs to ask Kathy Dunderdale "who owns the natural resources of this province?". If she replies by saying that they belong to the people, then she has no business arguing that the rich are paying more than their share.
******* Note on Calculations *******
Friday, December 28, 2012
The Anti-Avalon Bias of Provincial Election Boundaries
According to the Electoral Boundaries Act, section 15(1):
*********** Update ************
This chart shows the share of the province's population living in the St. John's census metropolitan area (CMA) versus the share of electoral districts.
"the commission shall ensure that the division of the province into districts and the description of the boundaries give primacy to the principle that the vote of every elector in the province shall have a weight equal to that of every other elector."
Let's consider how well this principle is being met by current boundaries. Since the 2006 redistribution there are 4 districts in Labrador, 19.5 on the Avalon, and 24.5 on the island outside of the Avalon (I've split Bellevue in half). The average populations of these districts from the 2011 census are as follows.
Region
|
Average Population
|
Labrador districts:
|
6700
|
Off-Avalon districts:
|
9200
|
Avalon districts:
|
13450
|
Avalon districts contain 50% more people than off-Avalon districts and twice as many as Labrador districts. Considered differently, the Avalon would have 5 more seats if the districts were evenly divided.
How did this happen? There are at least three contributing factors: the act requires four districts in Labrador, the boundaries were drawn using 2001 census numbers which don't account for net migration to the Avalon since then, and even based on the outdated 2001 figures the districts in the North-East Avalon were drawn about 15 percent larger than those outside of the Avalon.
The next redistribution of districts is scheduled for 2016, so unless the act is changed our next election will take place with these lopsided districts that are only getting worse. A change before the election would likely help the NDP, so it probably isn't going to happen.
Instead I'll make a more modest proposal. Why not postpone the redistribution until 2017 so the commission can use the 2016 census instead of the 2011 census? It's crazy to draw the boundaries just a few months before the new census data goes public. The commission might also be permitted to consider population growth projections when setting the boundaries so they don't become outdated as quickly.
This chart shows the share of the province's population living in the St. John's census metropolitan area (CMA) versus the share of electoral districts.
Friday, December 21, 2012
Fertility Rates in Newfoundland and Labrador
Update: The Sir Robert Bond Papers has written a response to this post here.
In 2007, the PC party of NL introduced a $1000 bonus for women who give birth or adopt a baby. The Sir Robert Bond Papers blog has recently run a series of posts analyzing the effect of this policy on birth rates, concluding that the effect has been small and temporary. There are a few problems with his analysis though, so I'd like to add to this discussion.
Firstly, his analysis considers only the number of births per year, which fails to account for changes in population and demographics. A better indicator is the fertility rate: the average number of live births a woman can expect in her lifetime based on age-specific fertility rates in a given year. Secondly, his analysis doesn't acknowledge that declining birth rates is a trend nation-wide and that provincial rates should be compared to what is happening in other provinces.
The following chart compares NL fertility rates to Canadian fertility rates. The rates are per 1000 women so a rate of 2000 means that the average woman will have 2 births in her lifetime based on that years stats.
This shows that fertility in NL is consistently below national averages, but has jumped much closer in recent years. The timing of that jump is easier to see by charting the difference in fertility rates by year.
The jump happened in 2008, the year after the new policy was enacted. Moreover, the difference has actually narrowed since then. Now I'm sure that the booming economy has a lot to do with this, but the data is entirely consistent with the PC baby bonus having a significant and enduring effect.
In 2007, the PC party of NL introduced a $1000 bonus for women who give birth or adopt a baby. The Sir Robert Bond Papers blog has recently run a series of posts analyzing the effect of this policy on birth rates, concluding that the effect has been small and temporary. There are a few problems with his analysis though, so I'd like to add to this discussion.
Firstly, his analysis considers only the number of births per year, which fails to account for changes in population and demographics. A better indicator is the fertility rate: the average number of live births a woman can expect in her lifetime based on age-specific fertility rates in a given year. Secondly, his analysis doesn't acknowledge that declining birth rates is a trend nation-wide and that provincial rates should be compared to what is happening in other provinces.
The following chart compares NL fertility rates to Canadian fertility rates. The rates are per 1000 women so a rate of 2000 means that the average woman will have 2 births in her lifetime based on that years stats.
This shows that fertility in NL is consistently below national averages, but has jumped much closer in recent years. The timing of that jump is easier to see by charting the difference in fertility rates by year.
The jump happened in 2008, the year after the new policy was enacted. Moreover, the difference has actually narrowed since then. Now I'm sure that the booming economy has a lot to do with this, but the data is entirely consistent with the PC baby bonus having a significant and enduring effect.
Tuesday, December 18, 2012
Council Meeting Fireworks
The following summary of tonight's St. John's Council meeting was written by Sherwin Flight.
Here's a basic rundown of what happened today at City Hall.
- At the very beginning, Mayor O'Keefe had everyone in the room stand for a minute of silence for the victims of the recent school shooting in the U.S. He talked about how safety is such an important thing, something we all need to focus on, and how the world just wasn't what it used to be. (More on this later)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








